No, what was actually surprising in tonight's episode is how close Rick seems to accepting the deal that the Governor offers. True, Michonne only completely became one of us last week (or even more recently in Walking Dead time). But it isn't like Rick not to have completely rejected the Governor's offer to leave in peace for the price of Michonne - who took out the Gov's eye - rather than going back to the prison and asking Hershel to talk him out of it.
Maybe Rick is still not completely recovered from Lori's death. Or maybe there is a deeper lesson here: when Rick asks Hershel if he would be willing to sacrifice his daughters, if there was any chance that giving up Michonne could save them, Hershel doesn't answer. He's the moral tower on the show, so, if he doesn't answer, does that mean Rick's not completely wrong to consider giving up Michonne?
I'm hoping there's something else going on. Rick also says that he expects the Governor will kill everyone even if Michonne is given up - which we the audience know is true. Is Rick thinking there's some sort of play in which he can pretend to give up Michonne, to get some sort of jump on the Governor?
Meanwhile, it's not as if the Governor is invulnerable. His seconds in command now both seem more decent than he, not to mention Andrea's continuing underlying affinity for our team. One thing is sure: The Walking Dead continues to present stories worthy of Greek tragedy and Shakespeare - that is, the human soul in the highest state of siege - in the wrappings of a good old zombie tale.
See also The Walking Dead 3.3 meets Meadowlands ... The Walking Dead 3.4: Going to the Limit ... The Walking Dead 3.9: Making Crazy Sense ... The Walking Dead 3.10: Reinforcements ... The Walking Dead 3.11: The Patch ... The Walking Dead 3.12: The Lesson of Morgan