Chuck Todd interviews me about alternate histories
Showing posts with label free will. Show all posts
Showing posts with label free will. Show all posts

Monday, April 13, 2020

Westworld 3.5: Ground Control



Let me just say that this third season of Westworld is so different from the first two that it seems more like a new sequel series than the third season of a single series.  The tableau certainly isn't the same.  Even the recurring characters, especially the multiple Dolores, are different.  But this new series is provocative and altogether excellent.  But you already knew that.

Tonight's episode 3.5 featured some great music and some notable, even crucial reveals.  Let's start with the reveals.

Serac's erstwhile bodyguard - his body now inhabited and animated by a Dolores - tells Bernard, "You're the only one we can't replace".  That's an extraordinarily important point.  Why is that?  Bernard's a host, so why can't he be replaced?  Because there's no master file of his mind or soul or whatever you want to call it?  I'm trying to recall if we've ever seen Bernard replaced in earlier seasons?  Were a bank of Bernards wiped out at the end of season two?  I'm not sure - perhaps the machines that control the world wiped out that part of my memory.

Then there's what that dying guy says to Caleb: "You did it".   Did what?  Of all the new characters this season, we still know the least about Caleb.  Was his running into Dolores the accident that it seemed to be?  Caleb apparently is an innocent, but also seems to have a reflexive understanding of the world around him.  The answer to who Caleb is will likely also explain why Dolores trusts him.

Third and last reveal I'll mention now: Serac saying that, although the super-AI machine his brother created and Serac now controls has immense and detailed power over people's lives, we humans still have a "bubble of agency" to do on occasion what we want to do. When those bubbles present themselves is of course not clear.  But they mean that anyone and everyone still have modicums (or modica?) of unpredictable free will.

Just like every time you sit down or stand up to play or sing a song.  Which brings me to the music in this episode.  It was especially good, via the "genre" Caleb was experiencing.  But I especially liked the violin instrumental rendition of David Bowie's "Space Oddity".  Can't get much better than that in depicting a world veering out of control.








They're coming out into the open, for the first time in centuries ....

Saturday, December 30, 2017

Chronological Order: Door to the Past, Literally

Chronological Order, the 2010 feature-length movie I just saw on Amazon Prime, certainly deserves an award, which would be for the most unlikely time-travel device I've ever come across on page or screen.  That would be a door that our protagonist, a guy by the name of Guy, finds floating in the ocean.  He and we soon learn that when he stands it up and walks through it, he walks a little or longer into the past.

That's a great set-up for a time-travel story in the science fantasy genre.  But the execution and development leaves a lot to be desired.  I'm always up for a low-key, slice-of-life presentation.  But Chronological Order is so low-key as to seem desultory, and although this reflects the persona and the predicament on the protagonist, it also makes it difficult for the viewer to keep focus or even, in my case, continuing interest.

Nonetheless, Chronological Order does have something, in its unusual set-up and even its meandering pace.  Lurking behind everything Guy does is the question of free will, which comes up whenever the time traveler in the present sees himself in the future, or when the unknowing time traveler in the past (before his present self has traveled to the past) sees his present self in the past for the first time.  If I'm wearing a blue shirt today, and I travel to the past to yesterday, where I see myself wearing that blue shirt, does that mean I in yesterday will have no choice but to put on that blue shirt when I get dressed today?  If the answer is yes, that negates or erases my free will to put on whatever shirt I please.

Guy wears lots of shirts in Chronological Order, and grapples with rather than explicates the inherent problem of free will in this story.  Just to be clear: I'm a firm believer in free will.  I don't believe it's a necessary illusion of intelligent life.  And it's one reason (in addition to the grandfather paradox, which can only be solved by the multiple-universe hypothesis, even more incredible than time travel) that I think time travel is impossible, whether low-key and unfocused or keenly drawn on a razor's edge.  Though, I've always admired a point that Chance (played by Hugh Laurie) made in the first season of that series on Hulu last year, "Someone once asked William James if he believed in Free Will. 'Of course,' James replied. 'What choice do I have?'"


watch The Chronology Protection Case FREE on Amazon Prime



  

read these time-travel stories FREE on Amazon Prime
InfiniteRegress.tv