Chuck Todd interviews me about alternate histories
Showing posts with label social media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label social media. Show all posts

Monday, November 9, 2026

What the Democratic Landslide Says About the Impact of Social Media?

 

more about The Silk Code here

Social media have been blamed by the best of 'em for the ascension of Trump, Trumpism, and Maga-Americans.  Andrey Mir convincingly argued in Postjournalism (2020) that the replacement of truth by likes and shares of posts as the goal on social media was responsible for the success of Trump and the Republican lies, and Ezra Klein ("I Didn’t Want It to Be True, but the Medium Really Is the Message", 2022, The New York Times) in a general way blamed social media, supported by McLuhan's the medium is the message, as the source of the successful assault on democracy in American politics.

So what are we to make of the profoundly comprehensive replacement of the Republican deceit with Democratic truth in the election last week?  Social media still prize likes and shares well above truth.  That's a fact.  But how to reconcile that fact with the proximate obvious fact that the Democrats did so well last week?

The answer must be that media determinism has its limits.  Yes, it influences and directs our behavior in many ways -- the success of advertising demonstrates that point -- but media are not the final word in what moves us to vote, and buy things, political and otherwise.  Decades ago, when my first novel The Silk Code was published by Tor Books, and began to sell very well, Tom Doherty, then head of Tor Books (now Chairman Emeritus of the Tor Group), took me to lunch, and asked me what I would like to see Tor do for the novel.  "How about a full-page ad in The New York Times?" I half-seriously replied, hoping to build on the good review that Gerald Jonas had just provided.  Tom smiled, and told me that years of publishing had taught him that an ad like that would likely result in a couple of hundred sales.  "Would what result in more sales?" I asked, between bitefuls of the delicious lunch.  "Word of mouth" from close relatives and close friends, he replied.

That was back in the Fall of 1999, a crucial few years before the advent of social media.  We certainly make friends of a kind on social media, but they are not the same as in-person friends and not at all the same as close relatives.   Those human relationships have far more sway than anything we may read, watch, or hear online.

And therefore I think the Democratic victory is not only good news indeed for humanity, but the result of the human thirst for truth, that transcends the power of social media. And therefore I think the Democratic victory is not only good news indeed for humanity, but the result of the human thirst for truth, that transcends the power of social media. The "autocratic breakthrough" is the term sociologists use to describe the instant when a democracy, besieged from the inside by people and groups who want to destroy it, who want to replace it with a dictatorship, achieve their goal. They work for years, chipping away at democratic practices, demonizing opponents, arresting them, imprisoning them, deporting them, killing them. They stock the government with their supporters. They replace the truth with lies. And though the people who believe in the democracy, who stand up to the fascist tide, do their best to oppose the destructive wave, they eventually are worn down, and the autocratic breakthrough happens. This is exactly what happened in Germany in 1934, when Hitler the Chancellor became Hitler the Führer. Our election last week defied the diminishment of truth in social media, and took a big step in making sure the autocratic breakthrough won't happen here.



Friday, July 8, 2022

Social Media and Mass Murder

Important conversation between Bob Mann and me on his Bob Mann Hot Media podcast about the role of social media in the mass murders that continue to erupt in the US.

 

Friday, November 19, 2021

Call for Papers: Special Issue of Studia Humanistyczne (in English) on The Future of Social Media

The Future of Social Media

Call for papers for special issue of Studia Humanistyczne AGH. Contribution to Humanities guest-edited by Paul Levinson, Fordham University

 

Social media are at a crisis crossroads here in the United States, and therefore the world.  Beginning with the election of Donald Trump to the US Presidency in 2016 and continuing with the fight against the deadly COVID19 pandemic, social media have been blamed for spreading misinformation and outright lies that have, in the case of COVID19, cost numerous human lives.  Calls have therefore arisen in the mass media and around the world for government regulation of social media.  But such regulation would run contrary to the tradition of a vibrant Internet, in which free expression flourishes. Indeed, such regulation could be a path towards the dissolution of democracy and the rise of fascism.

 

This special issue of Studia Humanistyczne AGH. Contribution to Humanities looks to explore all sides of this issue, around the world, in social media of any kind, via scholarly, well-researched and reasoned articles, 2000-6000 words in length, written in English. Appropriate topics would include:

 

·      Case studies that examine how disinformation on social media led to loss of life, endangerment of public health, etc.

·      Examination of elections in democracies which were adversely affected by disinformation on social media

·      Examples of how attempts to control social media backfired or succeeded in countries with authoritarian leadership

·      Proposals for moving forward in a way that limits disinformation but respects freedom in social media

 

Final articles will be due February 15, 2022.  Expected publication date will be June 2022.

 

Please send proposed title, draft abstract, and bio-brief by December 31, 2021 to Levinson.paul@gmail.com

 

After acceptance of the draft abstract, the manuscript should be submitted by the author on the journal platform: https://www.editorialsystem.com/shaghen

 

Studia Humanistyczne AGH. Contributions to Humanities provides immediate open access to its content on the principle that making research freely available to the public supports a greater global exchange of knowledge. Access and distribution is allowed under the CC BY 4.0 license. There is no fee for publishing in the Journal.  More information about the Journal: http://www.journalssystem.com/shagh/en

 

Detailed guidelines can be found at: http://www.journalssystem.com/shagh/Editorial-Rules,2335.html

InfiniteRegress.tv