"Paul Levinson's It's Real Life is a page-turning exploration into that multiverse known as rock and roll. But it is much more than a marvelous adventure narrated by a master storyteller...it is also an exquisite meditation on the very nature of alternate history." -- Jack Dann, The Fiction Writer's Guide to Alternate History

Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Obama's Powerful Health Care Speech, and the Same Old Republican Answer

Barack Obama gave a powerful, specific, inspiring speech to Congress and the American people tonight. He reached out to Republicans, saying he would pursue medical malpractice insurance reform, something Republicans have long and justifiably sought. He explained that he was not interested in ramming a public option down anyone's throat, only providing it as a choice for those who seek it. And even then, Obama made clear that what he's most interested in was significant reform, which could even be accomplished without a public option. He indicated that he would "call out" and otherwise not tolerate any misrepresentations of the health care reforms. And in Rooseveltian terms, he concluded by saying that he and Congress didn't come to Washington to fear the future, but to help shape it.

The Republican response? Rep. Boustany insisted that Republicans would stand firm against a government takeover of health care in the United States.

It would have been nice had the Republicans responded to the speech Obama delivered, rather than one they imagined. (Keith Olbermann made much the same point about Republicans responding to a non-existent speech.)

So where do we stand?

Obama has spelled out specific health care reforms. If Republicans don't want to seriously negotiate about this, Obama and the Democrats should move ahead without them. Tonight was an important step forward, with or without Republicans.

3 comments:

Carlos Rangel said...

Paul, it was dissapointing to view a prefabricated response that had nothing to do with the message from the president. It not only contradicted illogically the positions presented by the president, but it higlighted the ideology of opposition that we have seen over the last few months. In dismissing the goal of the president not to increase the deficit, it seems to highlight by default that the greater fiscal irresponsibility has come from those promising that "big business" is more effective than "big government".

Unknown said...

Is it just me? Or do the Republicans not understand what is happening. It like a viral meme has infected them. No matter what is said, they respond with the same statements. This is somethiung I fear can only be rectified by the proper education of the younger generation: Open your hearts and minds and hear what is being said.

Replic Jewelry said...

Despite hefty Democratic majorities in both the House and the Senate, centrists in Obama’s party have balked at the president’s proposal to create a public health care plan to compete with private insurers.
http://blogs.albawaba.com/replicajewelry

InfiniteRegress.tv