"Paul Levinson's It's Real Life is a page-turning exploration into that multiverse known as rock and roll. But it is much more than a marvelous adventure narrated by a master storyteller...it is also an exquisite meditation on the very nature of alternate history." -- Jack Dann, The Fiction Writer's Guide to Alternate History

Wednesday, November 5, 2008

Hologram of Jessica Yellin on CNN Last Night - I Saw Something Like This in 1979

How many of you saw Wolf Blitzer interviewing Jessica Yellin's hologram in CNN's coverage of the election returns last night? I you didn't, check it out below.

We've come a long way since Princess Leia in Star Wars. Back then, I wrote in my doctoral dissertation, "Human Replay: A Theory of the Evolution of Media" (1979), that "the third dimensional will replace the two dimensional image as surely and completely as color replaced black-and-white, and talkies replaced silent movies" (p. 282). But it's been a long time in coming - first developed back in 1949, we've seen holograms on credit cards and as special effects in movies. How close are we to seeing it a regular basis on television?

The better question is, how long will be it before our very televisions and movies and web screens are three dimensional - which show people, like Jessica Yellin, from all 360 degrees, from back, sides, and front, as she was standing there and talking to Wolf Blitzer in person?

High-definition television has taken us a big step closer, because the hologram needs a much better resolution of image than our older television screens provide. Fiber optic bandwidth increase has also been an important step towards holographic TV. But predicting the advent of a new medium in specific years is always a risky undertaking - the fax was invented back in the 1800s, and didn't become a major player in media until in the 1980s.

But, sooner or later, holography will be here. As I explain in my "anthropotropic" theory of media evolution, we invent technologies that communicate for us in increasingly human ways. Thus, as the above quote says, photography has evolved from black-and-white to color, silent to talking, still to moving - after all, we see in color, almost always hear some sound when we're looking at something, and the world is in motion. And just as dramatically as all that has happened, we will someday have holography for everything we see in our living rooms and on our desks and in the devices we carry and hold in our hands. The third dimensional is already part of our perception of the world. (See Human Replay: A Theory of the Evolution of Media and The Soft Edge: A Natural History and Future of the Information Revolution for more.)

In the meantime, here's Jessica Yellin ...



PS - added a few hours after the above -

Some people on Gizmodo and elsewhere are claiming that the Yellin appearance (and also a dance done on CNN by Wil.i.am) were not "really" holograms.

Here's the gist of the response I posted:

About the CNN holograms being "real" or not:

First, there of course were no three dimensional images walking around out of the screen in anyone's living room. So if that's what anyone means by saying no way these were holograms, that's of course correct.

But if we're referring to the fact that Blitzer was talking to an empty stage - not the hologram of Yellin - then I think what we saw can still be correctly called a hologram. We saw a three dimensional image within the TV frame, talking to the flesh-and-blood Blitzer. That image was still a hologram for us, the viewer, regardless of what Blitzer saw or didn't see.

Or, put otherwise, I don't see a meaningful difference between a hologram on a stage broadcast on TV, and a blank stage in which three dimensional information is synched into the broadcast from another source and looks three-dimensional on the 2-D screen at home.

Or, put additionally otherwise, I see no meaningful distinction in this context between (i) an illusion of an illusion or hologram and (ii) an illusion or hologram - no difference between (i) an illusion of an illusion and (ii) an illusion.

8 comments:

Jessica Knapp said...

I saw it ... and when I was done being freaked out by it ... I actuall thought of your theory.

If we're moving into holography to the extent you predict, I just hope it's a gradual move. I hate to sound so old at 30, but I found it all a little disturbing.

Paul Levinson said...

My theory also predicts that you'll learn to love it :)

Good to "see" you here, Jessica!

Anonymous said...

That's crazy!
As Wolf Blitzer would say, "Amazing, simply amazing."

badthing1 said...

Like yourself and many others, Prof, I too was excited when I saw it last night on CNN and my boyfriend Chris who is a Star Wars fanatic turned to me with glee and said, "I TOLD you that one day we would be seeing this on a tv broadcast!!!!!!!"

Isn't technology incredible? We believe that it is and will just get even MORE so as we evolve. :)

I just KNEW that you would do a post on this...

Paul Levinson said...

:) Thanks, badthing ... and, actually, yours and John's comment in one of my other threads ("I've Never Been Prouder of America") encouraged me to write this today!

You're a good influence...

Unknown said...

Firstly: What was done, is indeed impressive, and I don't want to be negative about the achievement.
BUT:
They succeeded in digitally capturing a 3D object. For there to be an actual hologram, there would have to be a projection of this digital capture as a holographic image. What we saw was merely a representation of a 3D object on a 2 DIMENSIONAL television screen.

What we saw was basically a PHOTOGRAPH of a digital "hologram"

Paul Levinson said...

I don't disagree - I'm just saying, that, from the perspective of the viewer of the 2-D televisions, there is no significant difference between (i) a hologram actually projected on the stage with Blitzer, and (ii) the 3-D information put into mix that went in the broadcast.

The real breakthrough will occur when we have a 3-D image jumping out of our screens in our living room.

Polilla said...

Other opinion about this: CNN's human 'hologram' on election night

InfiniteRegress.tv