As the Huffington Post noted last week, John Pike's pepper spraying of UC Davis students has become a massive meme of Internet ridicule. Jeanne Moos's CNN piece yesterday had some truly funny examples, my favorite probably being Pike as the cause of John Boehner's tears.
But I admit to having mixed emotions about this meme. On the one hand, Pike's act of casual depravity - pepper spraying non-violent students like "he was watering a garden," as Sharon Osbourne aptly put it - is deserving of all the cleansing ridicule the creative among us can bestow upon it. Humor is a good way of diffusing cultural pain, of sublimating the fury we feel at Pike's nonchalant cruelty, as per Freud.
On the other hand, maybe we don't want our anger sublimated all that much. Pike assaulted those students, plain and simple. He committed a crime that warrants not only conviction and punishment - as in jail - but maximum publicity in its raw form, to serve as a warning and reminder to other police officers to control themselves when they are attempting to control groups of people. All of that is no laughing matter.
Still, there is a healing quality in humor, in laughing at Pike's vent from hell aimed at everything from Mount Rushmore to the Beatles to Bambi. My other favorite is Pike showing up in prehistoric cave art - Pike as the demon of authoritarian violence which has beset our species from the beginning - and here's a shout-out to James McGrath's contribution (James' comment on my blog post here yesterday got me thinking about this).
Occupy Wall Street Chronicles, Part 1
But I admit to having mixed emotions about this meme. On the one hand, Pike's act of casual depravity - pepper spraying non-violent students like "he was watering a garden," as Sharon Osbourne aptly put it - is deserving of all the cleansing ridicule the creative among us can bestow upon it. Humor is a good way of diffusing cultural pain, of sublimating the fury we feel at Pike's nonchalant cruelty, as per Freud.
On the other hand, maybe we don't want our anger sublimated all that much. Pike assaulted those students, plain and simple. He committed a crime that warrants not only conviction and punishment - as in jail - but maximum publicity in its raw form, to serve as a warning and reminder to other police officers to control themselves when they are attempting to control groups of people. All of that is no laughing matter.
Still, there is a healing quality in humor, in laughing at Pike's vent from hell aimed at everything from Mount Rushmore to the Beatles to Bambi. My other favorite is Pike showing up in prehistoric cave art - Pike as the demon of authoritarian violence which has beset our species from the beginning - and here's a shout-out to James McGrath's contribution (James' comment on my blog post here yesterday got me thinking about this).
Occupy Wall Street Chronicles, Part 1
3 comments:
Unfortunately,some people feel authoritay's prior warning justifies gassing people exercising their Rights against the state.
http://www.breitbart.tv/video-proof-uc-davis-protesters-were-warned-before-pepper-spray-incident/
Yep - standard operating procedure for cops in many localities, who think failure to obey an order warrants violence by cops. And in complete disregard of the 2002 court decision that held pepper spray was warranted only to subdue violent subjects.
Thanks for the mention! I was in the same two minds as well, but it seemed both an important outlet for mockery of authority that might otherwise intimidate, and also too good an opportunity to create a Doctor Who-related image! :)
Post a Comment